The University of Western Australia

| uwa | csd | altmodes: modes - tools - examples |

Alternative Modes of Teaching and Learning

Alternative modes to delivery

Mentoring

Definition

A mentoring relationship is where one wiser and more experienced person assists another person to grow and to learn. It is not a new management technique. Since humans have lived in social groups we have learnt our norms, values and behaviours by the example and coaching of others.
It is arguably the most effective way to teach the desired way to do things and pass on a culture.

Wareing, I., Guidelines on Mentoring for Women. 1994, Woolloomooloo: NSW Ministry for the Status and Advancement of Women. p 48.

Moore and Salimbene (1981) define the mentoring relationship as an intense, lasting and professionally centered relationship between two individuals in which the more experienced and powerful individual, the mentor, guides, advises, and assists in any number of ways the career of the less experienced, often younger, upwardly mobile protégé. Given this definition, it is not surprising that mentoring is not a common experience. The relationship requires a long-term reciprocal commitment of energy and time. It requires two people who come together at a mutually opportune time and who respect and enjoy one another enough to spend significant amounts of time together. (Johnsrud, 1990, p. 58)

Johnsrud, L.K. (1990) Mentor Relationships: Those That Help and Those That Hinder, in Moore, K.M. & Twombly, S. B. (Eds) Administrative Careers and the Marketplace, New Directions for Higher Education no. 72, Winter 1990. Pp. 57-66.

Mentoring networks can be established between students, for example between second year and first year students to help the first year student settle in to their new environment and discipline.
Mentoring relationships can also be set up in order to support students in the development of a particular professional role, for example when they are on placements, doing projects, or on a service based learning assignment etc.

Student-student mentoring relationships are intended to assist less experienced students to adjust to university life through regular contact with and support from more experienced students. While these relationships may emerge informally on the basis of friendship or family ties, formal mentoring programmes established by a third party enable students from a range of backgrounds to benefit from the process.
Successful student-student mentoring programmes have been established in the School of Agriculture (at UWA) and also as part of the Women in Science and Engineering Programme at UWA, predominantly for first-year students. The booklet Friends in the Workplace: A mentoring scheme for UWA Students, produced by the Careers Service and also available from the Teaching and Learning Centre, is an excellent guide to establishing a formal mentoring programme for students.

Issues of Teaching and Learning, Vol 3, No. 3, April 1997, The University of Western Australia. http://www.csd.uwa.edu.au/newsletter/ issue0397/mentoring.html

Advantages

  • Provides learners with interpersonal support
  • Enables the passing on of relevant knowledged from a more experienced to a less experienced person
  • Develops confidence
  • Provides an entrée into relevant networks
  • Establishes a professional relationship
  • Can be equally beneficial for mentor

Disadvantages

  • Can be problematic if mentor and mentee not wwell-matched
  • Mentor needs to be skilled in communication and interpersonal skills
  • Time and work pressures may get in the way if not structured in

Resources and References

DeLiberations on Teaching and Learning in Higher Education
A Magazine for Academics, Librarians and Educational Developers

http://www.lgu.ac.uk/deliberations/home.html

Mentor 2000

http://home1.gte.net/mntr2000/contents.htm

The WWW - Opportunities for an Integrated Approach to Teaching and Research in Science

http://www.scu.edu.au/sponsored/ausweb/ausweb95/
papers/education1/riddle/

Valid HTML 4.0!

Hierarchical menu script available from <http://www.dhtmlab.com/>